- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Mark Topic as New
- Mark Topic as Read
- Float this Topic for Current User
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Mute
- Printer Friendly Page
Am i in the wrong?
for some context i am a 16 year old girl. I used to live in a different state. Most of my family lives in my old state, so every 2 or so months, i like to go back to visit them. My brother and i are the ones who do so as my parents have work, so we just go alone and live with my cousins. I have a large extended family, including 17 aunts and Uncles and countless more cousins. Most of my cousins are all older than my brother and I. So we dont really have a lot in common. My second oldest cousin, has 2 daughters, (9 and 6 respecitvely) and i live with her for the duration of my visit. I love my 2 little nieces so much and i adore all the time i spend with them. Because im very close with them, i always bring them gifts while i visit. My cousin doesnt speak english very well and is a bit unfarmiliar with things, so during our stay, my brother and i always go pick up our nieces from school.
One particular day, when we went to pick up my oldest niece, call her ava, she was obviously sad. not crying, but sad. I asked her why and she wouldn't tell me. After a while, she caved and told me this:
A girl, say her name is zoe, was picking on ava during lunch because ava's food "smelled bad". And this had been going on for a while. Every day, my cousin pack ava some sort of aisan food for lunch as thats the only thing she knows how to make. Ava's lunch mainly consisted of a small side dish of japanese seeweed salad or kimchi or bamboo shoots. The main, being something like fried rice, noodles or stir fry. And some aisan snacks. And this Zoe girl was complaing about how bad the food smelled.
Hearing this, i was kind of mad. So i asked ava to take me to see this zoe girl while my brother stayed in the car. We found zoe in the playground and i kindly tapped her on the shoulder. Now i wanst palning on lecturing a 9 yr old, but reminding her that is was wrong, but boy this kid was rude. first thing she did was say "hellaur?" very rhetorically and when i introduced myself, she laughed.
Me: im ava's -
Zoe: ahhahaha ava? Whats wrong
Me: well i wanted to remid you it is very rude to bully other students based on what the ea-
Zoe: eat? yeah i know.
me: huh?
Zoe: lady, im KOREAN. and today ava had kimchi. I dont know where she got that kimchi but its stinky. And definetly not real Kimchi. and i think thats a bit rude.
Before i could speak, Zoe's frickin mother lunged at us and joined this conversation:
Mother: well i think its a bit rude your engaging in such conversation with a little girl dont you thinkg? are you avas mother?
Me: im sorry but i -
Mother: Wow! a teen parent! no wonder! you need to better educated ava! Its not cultraly apropriate to be eating kimchi at school. Esspesially for us Koreans.
And then her mum just left saying " zoe dear, 15 more minutes of playing then we go"
I was just so sick of being interupted by this mother daughter duo so i straight up yelled at zoe.
i might of went a little bit overboard but to defend my niece, ill do it again. Well zoe broke into tears and ava and i left. The next day ava got in trouble with her teacher and parents were contacted. I arrived with my cousin to defend ava and apparently ava was suspended! SUSPENDED! a 9 year old. I cant help but think its cuz of what i said and none of this wouldnve happened if i just let it slide. Am i in the wrong?
Comments
Hi @cakepops_4ever 
This sounds very distressing but I think Ava can appreciate having someone understand her situation and be in her corner. I also think you were well intentioned in initially approaching the situation politely. Everything that transpired seemed to have happened so suddenly so it's only natural to have felt maybe frustrated and disrespected?
You acknowledge you might have gone overboard and it's always good to reflect on these kinds of sitautions afterwards. Especially when you've slept it off, there's less adenaline, etc. How have you been feeling recently?
Personally, I would refer to a trusted adult - especially teachers. That way you're not letting the situation slide but you are doing something about it and standing up for Ava at the same time.
Please let us know how you're going if you'd like to 🌻
Hey cakepops_4ever,
Welcome to ReachOut!
First and foremost I want to say good on you for standing up for someone. I believe Ava would be happy to have such a cool family member in their life. I can empathise with feeling upset at how Ava was being discriminated against based solely on their food alone, it takes a lot of courage to speak for someone. Remember to take care of yourself, have you been processing this alright?
And does Ava's parents know about the situation?
Kind regards,
~ Stego
Hi cakepops_4ever,
Thanks for sharing today! This sounds like a frustrating and distressing situation. I'm sorry to hear your young niece was experiencing bullying from another student, I can see how much you care for her wellbeing. It's understandable why you were angry at how Zoe treated Ava and then how Zoe and her mother spoke to you, I can imagine you were feeling quite disrespected.
I can understand your shock around Ava being suspended, from what you have described it sounds like Ava did not do anything. It might be worth looking into Ava's State's education rules around school suspension, like this one, you may be able to challenge Ava's suspension if you don't think these criteria/conditions have occurred.
In the shock and frustration of this incident, what have you been doing to look after yourself?
